OOmnistu

Blog / Security

Security

Thirteen tricks your apps can no longer legally play

India's consumer regulator has named and banned 13 dark patterns - from fake 'only 2 left' counters and pre-ticked insurance boxes to hidden cancel buttons and silent trial-to-paid conversions. What each trick looks like, what the law still permits, what platforms must now prove, and where to complain.

OOmnistu
Reviewed 2026-11-21 · 7 min read

If you shop online in India, you have probably met the countdown timer that resets when you reload, the insurance box that arrives pre-ticked, the subscription that can be started in two taps but cancelled only after a phone call. Since 30 November 2023 each of these has a legal name and a legal status. The Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA), using its powers under section 18 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, notified the Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Dark Patterns, 2023, and clause 4 of those guidelines is as blunt as regulation gets: no person, including any platform, shall engage in any dark pattern practice. The guidelines bind every platform that systematically offers goods or services in India - wherever the company is headquartered - along with advertisers and sellers on those platforms.

What counts as a dark pattern

The definition is behavioural: any practice or deceptive design pattern in a user interface or user-experience flow that is designed to mislead or trick users into doing something they did not originally intend or want to do, by subverting or impairing their autonomy, decision-making or choice, in a way that amounts to a misleading advertisement, an unfair trade practice or a violation of consumer rights. Annexure 1 of the guidelines then names thirteen specified dark patterns, and the list is open-ended - the CCPA can specify more. Three of them work on pressure. False urgency is falsely stating or implying scarcity or urgency: the "Only 2 rooms left! 30 others are viewing this" banner with no basis, or a sale called "exclusive, today only" that runs every day. Confirm shaming is the guilt-trip copy - the flight site that makes you click "I will stay unsecured" to decline insurance, or "charity is for rich, I don't care" to skip a donation. Nagging is the repeated, disruptive prompt - the endless app-download pop-up, or cookie and notification requests with no "No" option - unless you have specifically permitted the interruptions.

The money traps

Five patterns sit on the payment path. Basket sneaking adds something to your cart at checkout without your consent so you pay more than the price of what you chose - the pre-ticked travel insurance, the salon subscription that joins your haircut, the charity donation that appears by default. Drip pricing hides elements of the price until late in the journey, charges more at payment than the checkout showed, advertises a product as free when continued use needs an in-app purchase, or blocks a service you already paid for until you buy something extra. Forced action makes you do something unrelated to get what you came for: subscribing to a newsletter to complete a purchase, downloading a second app to use the first, or handing over Aadhaar or credit-card details the purchase does not need. Subscription trap is the asymmetry between joining and leaving: cancellation made impossible, complex or hidden, ambiguous cancellation instructions, or demanding card details and auto-debit mandates for a "free" trial. And SaaS billing covers the quiet recurring charge - a free trial that converts to paid with no notification, silent auto-renewals, billing for features never used, or shady card-authorisation practices.

Misdirection and outright fraud

Four more patterns manipulate what you see. Interface interference highlights what the platform wants and buries what it does not - the pale, tiny "No" against the big bright "Yes", or an X on a pop-up that opens another ad instead of closing. Bait and switch advertises one outcome and serves another: the attractively priced product that turns "out of stock" the moment it hits your cart, with a pricier lookalike ready. Disguised advertisement dresses an ad up as something else - an influencer post, a news article, user content - and the guidelines pull in the separate 2022 misleading-advertisement guidelines here, with the disclosure duty sitting on the seller or advertiser whose content it is. Trick question uses confusing wording or double negatives so the option you pick is not the one you meant. The thirteenth, rogue malware, is not marketing at all: scareware and ransomware fronts, typically on piracy sites, that fake a virus warning to sell a "removal tool" that is itself the malware, or lock your files and demand payment.

What is not a dark pattern

The guidelines carry their own carve-outs, and they matter for any complaint. Basket sneaking does not cover free samples, complimentary services, or necessary fees disclosed at the time of purchase - delivery charges, gift wrapping, government taxes, or any charge explicitly disclosed when you buy. A marketplace is not liable under drip pricing for price fluctuations caused by its third-party sellers or other factors beyond its control. Nagging is not nagging if you specifically permitted the interruptions. False urgency requires the claim to be false - a genuinely accurate low-stock counter is legal. And the Annexure's illustrations are expressly guidance, not binding interpretations: the facts of each case decide.

What enforcement looks like

Because a dark pattern is by definition an unfair trade practice or misleading advertisement, the Consumer Protection Act's machinery attaches to it. After investigation, the CCPA can order discontinuation of the practice, recall of goods or withdrawal of services, and reimbursement to buyers (section 20). For misleading advertisements it can impose penalties up to Rs 10 lakh on manufacturers, endorsers and publishers, rising to Rs 50 lakh for subsequent contraventions (section 21). Ignoring a CCPA direction is itself an offence - up to six months' imprisonment, or a fine up to Rs 20 lakh, or both (section 88) - and causing a misleading advertisement to be made carries up to two years' imprisonment and a Rs 10 lakh fine, rising to five years and Rs 50 lakh for every subsequent offence (section 89). Separately, the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules, 2020 already ban automatic consent: under Rule 4(9), quoted in the CCPA's own advisory, your consent to a purchase must be an explicit, affirmative act - no pre-ticked checkboxes. In June 2025 the CCPA advised every e-commerce platform to self-audit for dark patterns within three months and encouraged public self-declarations of compliance, which it now publishes; it also noted it had already issued notices to platforms in certain cases.

What changes on 1 January 2027

The Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) (Amendment) Rules, 2026 - notified on 9 September 2026 and in force from 1 January 2027 - convert the voluntary audit into a binding duty. A new Rule 4(15) requires every e-commerce entity to comply with the 2023 guidelines, conduct a yearly self-audit to keep its platform free of dark patterns, and prominently display a certificate to that effect. The same amendment requires sponsored listings to be distinctly identified with clear and prominent disclosure (Rule 4(12)), forces platforms that announce a price cut to show the prior price - defined as the lowest price in the thirty days before the announcement (Rule 4(13)) - obliges them to name the seller on invoices in the same font size as their own name (Rule 4(14)), bans manipulating search results against the user's query (Rule 4(11)(c)), and puts explicit clocks on every platform's grievance officer: acknowledge a complaint within 48 hours and redress it within one month (substituted Rule 4(5)).

How to complain, and what wins one

Start with the platform's grievance officer - every e-commerce entity must appoint one and publish their contact details. If that fails, the National Consumer Helpline (1915, or 1915 or consumerhelpline.gov.in) registers complaints and refers them onward; the consumer commissions under the Act - district, state and national, by claim size - can order refunds, compensation and discontinuation of the practice; and the CCPA itself acts where the harm affects consumers as a class. What makes a complaint land is evidence of the trick as you met it: screenshots of the pre-ticked box or the price jump between checkout and payment, the screen recording of a cancellation flow with no cancel button, the trial terms that never mentioned conversion. Name the pattern when you file - the thirteen definitions give you the vocabulary the regulator itself uses.

Sources: the CCPA's Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Dark Patterns, 2023 (gazette notification CG-DL-E-30112023-250339 of 30 November 2023, in force on publication) for the definition, scope, prohibition and all thirteen Annexure 1 patterns with their provisos; the CCPA's advisory of 5 June 2025 for the self-audit direction, the notices already issued and the Rule 4(9) pre-ticked-checkbox quotation; the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) (Amendment) Rules, 2026 (G.S.R. 789(E), 9 September 2026, in force 1 January 2027) for the yearly audit, certificate, sponsored-listing, prior-price, invoice and grievance-clock provisions, corroborated by the Press Information Bureau release of 10 September 2026; the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 for sections 20, 21, 88 and 89; and consumerhelpline.gov.in for the National Consumer Helpline complaint route. All sources read on 21 November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

The insurance box on my checkout arrived already ticked - is that illegal?

Yes. Adding a paid ancillary service to your cart without your consent is basket sneaking, one of the thirteen banned patterns, and the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules, 2020 independently require your consent to any purchase to be explicit and affirmative - Rule 4(9) expressly rules out pre-ticked checkboxes. Charges that are necessary and disclosed when you buy, such as delivery fees or government taxes, are not basket sneaking.

A booking site warned "Only 2 rooms left" - is that automatically a dark pattern?

Only if the claim is false or misleading. False urgency means falsely stating or implying scarcity or urgency - invented viewer counts, made-up demand, or an "exclusive, today-only" sale that repeats. A stock counter that accurately reflects inventory is permitted.

My free trial became a paid subscription without any warning - what applies?

Two patterns: converting a trial to paid without notifying you is SaaS billing, and demanding your payment details or auto-debit authorisation to start a free subscription at all is a subscription trap. Cancellation must also be possible, visible and straightforward - hiding it or making it complex is itself a specified pattern.

The price at payment was higher than the price at checkout - is that drip pricing?

Charging more than the amount disclosed at checkout is drip pricing under the guidelines. One carve-out: a marketplace is not liable for price changes caused by third-party sellers on its platform or other factors beyond its control - so the same jump may be lawful on a marketplace but not from a direct seller.

Where do I complain about a dark pattern?

Complain first to the platform's grievance officer, whose details must be published. Then the National Consumer Helpline (1915, the NCH app or consumerhelpline.gov.in). Consumer commissions - district, state or national by claim size - can order refunds, compensation and discontinuation, and the CCPA takes up cases affecting consumers as a class. Keep screenshots or recordings of the trick as evidence.