Progressive web app or native app? A decision guide
Compare PWA and native approaches against required features, supported devices, distribution needs and maintenance responsibilities.
What a PWA is
According to web.dev's PWA course (https://web.dev/learn/pwa/getting-started), Progressive Web Apps are still websites, with enhanced features and capabilities. They are not tied to a technology stack: PWA is a pattern, not a single technology. The core pieces are a web app manifest and a service worker (https://web.dev/learn/pwa/welcome). Service workers can support caching, selected offline experiences and push notifications, subject to implementation and browser/OS support. They do not guarantee fast loading, offline completion of every action or push delivery on every platform.
web.dev's core checklist says a PWA should start fast and stay fast, work in any browser, respond to any screen size, provide a custom offline page, and be installable. Its optimal list adds a real offline experience for features that do not need a connection.
What the source says you can do with one
- You can start small: a basic manifest, a simple offline page, and a service worker that serves it and caches some critical CSS and JavaScript.
- You can pick one feature, such as push notifications.
- You can make one user journey work offline-first.
- You can wrap a PWA for stores such as Google Play or the Windows Store, and web.dev says that gives one app for everyone and saves costs and time. That is web.dev's claim, not a measured result.
How to decide (Omnistu reasoning, not from the source)
| Your situation | Lean toward |
|---|---|
| Content or catalogue is already a website; you want installability and offline basics | PWA |
| Limited budget and one team | PWA first, as web.dev's "start small" approach allows |
| You need deep device features or app-store-only distribution | Check the exact feature on each platform before choosing; web.dev's pages above do not cover platform-by-platform support |
| You need a full-featured experience tuned to one platform | Native |
Questions to answer before deciding
- Which three features do users need on day one?
- Do any depend on hardware or system features the browser may not give you? List them and test each on target devices.
- Do you need to be in an app store? If yes, check whether a PWA wrapper meets that store's rules, which this article does not verify.
- Who will maintain it, and in which language?
Limits
We did not benchmark PWAs against native apps, and this article makes no claim about speed, conversion or cost differences. Browser support changes, so check current support for each feature you rely on.
By Omnistu.