Beyond the OTP: the authentication rules behind every Indian digital payment
Since April 2026 every non-exempt digital payment in India runs on RBI's two-factor rule - one factor unique to that transaction unless the physical card is present - and your bank, not the regulator, decides whether you prove yourself with an OTP, a fingerprint, a device token or a PIN. The exemptions, the extra checks on unusual transactions, and the full-compensation promise for losses from transactions that skip the rules.
Pay for something online in India and the ritual is automatic: card number, then the SMS OTP. That ritual is a habit, not the law. The Reserve Bank of India (Authentication Mechanisms for Digital Payment Transactions) Directions, 2025 - issued on 25 September 2025 with compliance required by 1 April 2026 - set the actual rule: every digital payment transaction, unless exempted, must be authenticated by at least two distinct factors, but no specific factor is mandated, and an OTP is simply the one the ecosystem settled on. Your fingerprint, a device token, a PIN, a passphrase, the card hardware itself, Aadhaar-based or device-native biometrics - all of these sit in the Directions' own list of valid factors, and your issuer may let you choose among them.
The baseline rule and its two riders
The Directions bind every payment system provider and participant, bank and non-bank alike, for all domestic digital payment transactions. Two riders shape what you experience. First, for everything except a card-present transaction - tapping or inserting the physical card - at least one of the two factors must be dynamic: the proof of possession sent with the transaction must be unique to that transaction. A static password plus a static card number is not enough; the OTP, the token cryptogram or the signed challenge is what makes the second factor live. Second, the two factors must be independent - compromising one must not affect the reliability of the other. The Directions also force openness: authentication and tokenisation services must be accessible to all applications and token requestors working in the same operating environment, so a wallet or merchant app cannot be locked out of the authentication mechanism its own rails depend on.
What your bank may do differently now
Two provisions explain most of what is changing on your phone. Issuers may offer a choice of authentication factors - which is why some banks and apps now present a fingerprint or a device-bound approval instead of an SMS, perfectly legally. And issuers may run a risk-based approach: transactions can be scored against behavioural and contextual parameters - location, your usage patterns, device attributes, your transaction history - and anything that looks unusual can attract checks beyond the two factors. The Directions even name DigiLocker as a platform issuers may use to notify you and take confirmation for high-risk transactions. A payment that occasionally asks for an extra step is this rule working, not a malfunction.
The compensation promise
Paragraph 9 carries the consumer teeth: if any loss arises out of transactions effected without complying with these Directions, the issuer shall compensate the customer for the loss in full, without demur. Read the scope exactly as written: it covers losses from transactions that bypassed these authentication rules - say a non-exempt payment the system let through on a single static factor. Fraud that happened despite compliant authentication follows the separate liability framework, with its own reporting windows; our piece on when the bank must pay you back after fraud covers that side. The Directions also oblige issuers to adhere to the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 in handling the data these mechanisms generate.
What is exempt from two factors
Annexure-1 lists the live exemptions, and only these: small-value contactless card transactions; recurring payments under the e-mandate framework after the first transaction; select prepaid instruments (PPI-MTS and gift PPIs); NETC transactions - the FASTag lane; small-value digital payments in offline mode; travel bookings through commercial or corporate cards; and UPI Tap-and-Pay on NFC-enabled point-of-sale machines, an exemption added by a letter of 2 September 2026. The first debit of a new subscription or mandate still goes through full authentication. Eight older circulars are repealed by Annexure-2 - including the 2016 relaxation that let card-network solutions skip the additional factor for online payments up to Rs 2,000 - so the Annexure-1 list is the complete current set.
Paying on foreign websites
The Directions themselves are domestic-only, but two cross-border card obligations fell due on 1 October 2026 and are now in force. For a non-recurring, cross-border card-not-present transaction - the classic purchase from an overseas website - your card issuer must validate the transaction where the overseas merchant or acquirer requests authentication, and issuers had to register their Bank Identification Numbers with the card networks to make that work. A risk-based mechanism must also cover all cross-border CNP transactions. The practical translation: expect authentication prompts on more foreign checkouts than before, but not all - the duty attaches where the merchant side asks for it.
What stays the same
None of this removes the OTP; it remains a valid factor and the default most issuers still use. What changed is that the OTP is now one option among several the rules recognise, that at least one factor must be transaction-unique for anything other than a physically presented card, that exemptions form a closed list, and that a transaction pushed through outside these rules puts the bill on the issuer. If a payment of yours ever completes without the authentication the rules require and you lose money, cite paragraph 9 when you complain - and escalate to the RBI Ombudsman through cms.rbi.org.in if the bank does not resolve it.
Sources: the RBI (Authentication Mechanisms for Digital Payment Transactions) Directions, 2025 (RBI/2025-26/79, 25 September 2025, compliance by 1 April 2026), read in full including Annexure-1 (the seven current exemptions, with the UPI Tap-and-Pay addition of 2 September 2026) and Annexure-2 (the eight repealed circulars) - paragraph 6 for the two-factor, dynamic-factor and independence rules, paragraph 7 for interoperability, paragraph 8 for risk-based checks and DigiLocker, paragraph 9 for the full-compensation promise, and paragraph 10 for the cross-border card obligations that fell due 1 October 2026. Read on 21 November 2026.
Frequently asked questions
My app approved a payment with my fingerprint and no OTP - is that allowed?
Yes. The RBI's 2025 Directions require two factors of authentication unless the transaction is on the exemption list, but do not mandate any specific one. A fingerprint or other biometric - device-native or Aadhaar-based - is a valid factor, and issuers may offer you a choice. For anything other than a physically presented card, at least one factor must be unique to that transaction, which biometric approval mechanisms are built to provide.
A payment went through without any second factor and I lost money - who pays?
The issuer. Paragraph 9 of the Directions says that if a loss arises from transactions effected without complying with these authentication rules, the issuer must compensate the customer in full, without demur. Cite that paragraph in your complaint; if the bank does not resolve it, escalate free through the RBI Ombudsman at cms.rbi.org.in. Fraud on a properly authenticated transaction follows the separate liability framework instead.
Do subscriptions and standing instructions need an OTP every month?
No. The first transaction setting up an e-mandate goes through full authentication; the recurring debits after that are on the exemption list. The same closed exemption list covers small-value contactless taps, FASTag (NETC), offline small-value payments, gift and meal prepaid instruments, corporate travel cards, and UPI Tap-and-Pay on NFC terminals.
A foreign website took my card payment without an OTP - is that against the rules?
Not necessarily. The Directions apply to domestic transactions. Since 1 October 2026 your card issuer must validate a non-recurring cross-border online transaction where the overseas merchant or acquirer asks for authentication, and must run risk-based checks on all such transactions - but a foreign checkout that never requests authentication is outside that specific duty.
Why do some of my payments get extra verification steps while others sail through?
The Directions expressly allow risk-based checking: issuers may score transactions against your location, behaviour patterns, device attributes and history, and add checks beyond the two factors for anything that looks unusual. They may even use DigiLocker to notify you and confirm high-risk transactions. An occasional extra step is the rule operating as designed.